Post image for Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog

Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog

by Dr Egg

The lovely Dr Egg, Give A Brick treasurer and all round nice guy, has been rather quiet on here of late. However, he’s written a fascinating article about how science really does prove that being happy is good for you. It’s a little longer than our average post but is really worth taking the time to enjoy so if you’re in a rush, be sure to bookmark it ;) Over to you Dr Egg …

I thought I’d drop a line on this subject as I have been very conscious while reading quite a number of the posts and comments on the Give a Brick website that many relate to individual well-being. Examples include “How to bottle what makes your heart sing” “How to keep going when your world falls down” and “5 easy ways to live in the moment.” There is a common theme running through here and believe it or not it’s psychoneuroimmunology.

A bit of background: my day job (the one that pays the mortgage) is in health protection, a branch of public health and to do with the prevention and management of incidents and outbreaks, primarily communicable diseases. As a microbiologist by background, who spent his formative years in the Royal Navy and a couple of years at the Royal Marine training establishment, I became very interested in the, “Mind over matter” attitude of super fit young men or those aspiring to be super fit.

Now that’s not, “I don’t mind and you don’t matter;” military training is an expensive and serious business and having selected those who will be offered training, all branches of the services are desperate for their recruits to succeed. I was fortunate therefore to spend some time when working out of the Royal Naval Hospital, Haslar and the Institute of Naval Medicine, to be part of a project looking at whether there were any additional measures that could be taken to identify those Royal Marine recruits who were more likely to fail. This would allow for more discriminative selection, reduce wastage from the programme and provide advice on improvements prior to re-application to the service.

We were looking at a whole series of biochemical, haematological and immunological markers, way out of the comfort zone of a microbiologist. However, when I started reading around the issue, I discovered there were plenty of microbiological examples, as well as more sinister effects associated with various cancers. In “How to bottle what makes your soul sing” Eleanor talked about focussing on events that had a positive effect on you.

The world of psyconeuroimmunology has tended to focus on the effects of the negative and in particular within the realms of Major Life Events. The reason for this is that science can be a pretty blunt measuring instrument and needs to look at big things to see small changes. By concentrating on major life events, such as bereavement, job-loss, house moving, divorce, researchers were able to study people who had been traumatised and measuring the effects in terms of illness.

One study I remember (this is not a scientific treatise so please don’t ask me for proper references) looked at three groups of women, one group happily married, another who were widowed many years previously and a third group whose husbands had recently died. They found that this third group were more likely to die a cancer related death in the follow-up period of the study.

The group who were widowed many years previously, were of course the survivors from the past bereavement while those happily married equally had no major current stressors in their lives. The group that was recently widowed, as a group, were suffering all sorts of psychological traumas as they tried to come to terms with their loss.

As researchers studied the various medical markers, they found that the psychological effect of the stressors were influencing the immunological response to both infections as well as cells that were becoming cancerous. Now the positive side of this effect is the accounts you will read of people who are taught to think positively in response to their cancers; something that has been advocated very well by many women’s magazines in relation to breast cancer.

One of the most wonderful accounts I read of this was of how some paediatricians working with children with leukaemia, got them playing on one of the earliest computer games ever invented – Space Invaders. I’m sure you will remember; those funny little blobs moving down the cathode ray screen as you fired at them to destroy them. After the children had got to play for a while, the doctor’s told the children about the cells in their bodies that were invading them. They told them how they had a wonderful body with special weapons (the various cells and constituents of the immune system). They said how they needed to think about those abnormal cells invading their bodies and fire at them with their special weapons.

As in any such study, there were inevitably two groups, those who were on regular treatments and those who were also on identical regular treatments but also went through the space invader programme. No guesses at the result – the group who had been taught to fight their leukaemia had a far better survival rate.

So go on, smile, think positive thoughts and be positive to others – it’s good for your health and probably for theirs also.

Leukaemia Research - London Bikeathon 2009
Creative Commons License photo credit: HowardLake

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

Ben
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 5:01 pm

Oh my geek brain hurts.

A great insight in to the scientific power of emotions. Thanks for sharing.

I think what a lot of people miss is that happiness is a state that you change get in and out of in a split second, all you have to do is change your mindset. A great example of this is when you’re feeling really down and miserable, if you can think about a time when you felt complete joy and happiness you’ll smile. If you keep nurturing those positive feelings you’ll come out of your down time and you’ll be able to see the problems you face in a much more positive mindset.

I choose happiness always.
Ben´s last blog ..Doing something because you think you should, isn’t the way to go My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Dr Egg
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 5:23 pm

Thanks Ben. Reminds me of a scene from the dramatisation of Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple (with the real owner of the part – Joan Hickson), who marvels at the way an actress in a scene physically blanches as she is told bad news. My youngest daughter has learned to do the same thing in her acting parts. We watched her in one of her college test pieces and as she got angry, her face went physically white as she “owned” the part she was playing. Actors do it as you say by carefully remembering their emotions in given situations and then recall them when they need them in a dramtic part they are playing.

Being in an emotionally positive place can be switched to very quickly and is physically beneficial, as you say.

Ever heard the saying, “Hypochondriacs die young?” A scientific reality. Happiness is life enhancing and prolonging.
Dr Egg´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Ben
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 5:26 pm

Wow I never heard that saying. I really like it.
Ben´s last blog ..Doing something because you think you should, isn’t the way to go My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Karen
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 6:06 pm

Very interesting article, thanks for sharing.

I think it’s important to also realize that we are not happy all of the time (nor should we be). Your level of happiness increases and decreases over time and in response to different life situations. However, I have recently learned that everyone has a ‘happy set point’ so if you a person who has a high set point, no matter what happens in your life, you will go back to that level of happiness. I wonder if we can change our ‘happy set points’ or if it’s like genetics and we are born with it? Hmmm, interesting.

I had no idea of the ‘psyconeuroimmunology’ term so I have learned something new today :-)

Karen
Karen´s last blog ..Why It’s Never Too Late For Your Dreams To Come True My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Dr Egg
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 9:00 pm

Hi Karen,

Check out the quick guide in Wikipedia at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychoneuroimmunology

You’re absolutely right about not needing to be in a happy place all the time. Stressors of the right amount can ensure our performance is at it’s peak. It is indeed, all about balance.
Dr Egg´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Ryan Hanzel
Twitter:
February 7, 2010 at 9:22 pm

This was very educational, I am not familiar with many of the medical/scientific terms and this is the first time hearing about Psychoneuroimmunology. I don’t really know what to add except that I will keep this post in mind since my family has a history of cancer and I am a nicotine user. Just felt like I should comment since I did find this post moving and well presented. I will be reading up on that wiki link you commented on my post, waiting for a little more rest tho. Great work tho.
Ryan Hanzel´s last blog ..Being a loving person My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Eleanor
Twitter:
February 8, 2010 at 12:10 am

I really enjoyed this too. Glad we decided to publish it on a Sunday with Dr Egg around to add some follow-up. And on his birthday too ;)

It reminds me of a book I never got to the end of called ‘Why Zebras don’t get ulcers’ Worth a read if you’re into how your emotional state affects your health.

Reply

Roy February 9, 2010 at 9:14 pm

Very interesting post, maybe why those ‘alternative therapies’ work. Nothing wrong with an aromatherapy session that you believe helps you fight off an illness/depression whatever. Another insight (of sorts) I had while reading. Not so long ago I spent a couple of time with my Daughter in an adolescent unit in a London hospital, she has learning difficulties. She was very ill, yet never lost her trust in people who always look after her. Other teenagers there had major problems adjusting to being ill, and coping. She had quite major surgery and has made a superb recovery. Did her learning difficulty and lack of comprehension of how serious things were actually help her recover? The mind (brain) is an amazing thing.

Reply

Dr Egg
Twitter:
February 9, 2010 at 9:57 pm

Hi Roy,

You’re absolutely right, belief that some process is good for you will indeed have a positive effect and will have a role in alternative therapies. This will be enhanced if the therapy is not on the NHS and you have to pay for it yourself. This reinforces the message in your head. That said, there is also often a clear scientific benefit for some of the alternative therapies and I for one, will advocate anything that is having a benefit for a patient. I have in the past given a lecture on, “The Science of Old-Wives Tales.”

Interesting too what you say about your daughter. That absolute faith may well have been at work here. I have been quoted by the BBC in the past (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/south_east/3199769.stm) over my concerns in relation to the fear we can induce in people going into hospital and the worries they now have about healthcare associated infections. If you are worried about infection or have other anxieties, then this can have a negative effect on the immune system and put the individual at increased risk of infection. As mentioned in the main article, very difficult to demonstrate this on an individual scale but on a population basis with major life events, the effects become meassurable.

I am as equally amazed at the way the brain works, as you say.
Dr Egg´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: